Kishtwar: Slain SPOs were fired at from different directions
Source Entity
Arun Sharma

Two Special Police Officers (SPOs) were killed in a mysterious shooting in the Kishtwar forests, with autopsy reports indicating bullet wounds from multiple directions. The incident has prompted calls for a formal inquiry amid allegations of potential friendly fire.
The Kishtwar Tragedy: Unraveling a Tactical Ambush
The discovery of the bodies of two Special Police Officers (SPOs) in the Dharna area of Kishtwar on November 12 has sent shockwaves through the region. Bobby Chand, aged 57, and Rachpal Kumar, aged 45, were found dead in the forest, marking a somber moment for the Jammu and Kashmir Police force. The circumstances surrounding their deaths remain deeply obscured, with official silence contrasting sharply with the gravity of the incident.
Autopsy Findings and Ballistic Implications
Detailed insights from the post-mortem examinations provide a chilling account of the final moments of the two officers. Autopsy reports revealed that Bobby Chand sustained two gunshot wounds, while Rachpal Kumar suffered five. Crucially, officials noted that the bullets exited the bodies, and the trajectory analysis suggests the officers were targeted from multiple directions simultaneously. This tactical detail is significant, as it indicates a level of coordination usually associated with organized militant ambushes rather than accidental encounters.
The Controversy of Friendly Fire
Despite the apparent precision of the attack, the incident has been mired in controversy. Prominent politicians have publicly questioned the official narrative, specifically raising concerns regarding the possibility of 'friendly fire.' This allegation suggests that the officers may have been caught in crossfire or misidentified by fellow security personnel during an operation. The lack of an immediate, clear explanation from police authorities has only fueled public speculation and intensified demands for a transparent, independent investigation.
Security Context in Kishtwar
Kishtwar has long been a challenging terrain for security operations, characterized by dense forests and mountainous topography that complicate search-and-seize missions. The loss of two experienced SPOs highlights the persistent vulnerability of security personnel patrolling these volatile zones. The methodology of the shooting—multi-directional fire—suggests that regardless of whether the source was hostile or accidental, the operational environment in this sector is fraught with extreme risk.
The Path Toward Accountability
As the investigation continues, the primary challenge for authorities will be to bridge the gap between technical ballistic evidence and the emerging rumors of internal procedural failure. The demand for an inquiry is not merely a political gesture but a reflection of the urgent need for clarity among the families of the deceased and the broader public. Establishing whether this was a targeted militant strike or a tragic internal error is essential for maintaining morale and operational safety within the Jammu and Kashmir Police.
Conclusion and Future Implications
The deaths of Bobby Chand and Rachpal Kumar serve as a stark reminder of the complexities involved in maintaining security in Jammu and Kashmir. Moving forward, the findings of the investigative team will be pivotal. A transparent resolution will be necessary to prevent the erosion of public trust in security institutions, as the administration balances the need for operational security with the moral imperative to provide families with the truth regarding the loss of their loved ones.