Entertainment
The Indian Express

‘What did I do to ancestors?’: Shanaya Kapoor hits back at trolls over SOTY: After Dark

Source Entity

The Indian Express

November 19, 2026
‘What did I do to ancestors?’: Shanaya Kapoor hits back at trolls over SOTY: After Dark

Actor Shanaya Kapoor has responded to online backlash regarding her performance in the new JioHotstar series 'Student of the Year: After Dark'. Despite harsh critical reviews labeling the show incoherent, Kapoor has chosen to address the criticism with humor on social media.

The Digital Backlash: Shanaya Kapoor and the SOTY Legacy

The recent release of Student of the Year: After Dark on JioHotstar has placed actor Shanaya Kapoor at the center of a significant digital firestorm. As a spin-off of the highly recognizable Student of the Year franchise—originally helmed by Karan Johar—the series attempts a drastic tonal shift toward the thriller genre. However, the reception has been largely negative, with critics pointing toward a lack of narrative coherence and execution issues that have left audiences polarized.

Navigating the Trolls with Humor

In an era where celebrity interactions are mediated almost entirely through social media, Kapoor’s response to the criticism has been notable for its lightheartedness. By sharing an Instagram video where she cheekily addresses her detractors—asking, "What did I do to ancestors?"—Kapoor is employing a modern PR strategy of reclaiming the narrative. Instead of engaging in a defensive posture, she acknowledges the "roasting" while simultaneously pivoting back to the promotion of her work, demonstrating a resilient approach to the pressures of digital stardom.

The Critical Perspective: A Symptom of Streaming Trends

Beyond the personal backlash, the critical response to the series has been scathing. Reviewers have described the show as lacking the finesse expected from professional streaming productions, with comparisons drawn to amateur school-level skits. The core critique suggests that the show prioritizes a "wannabe" thriller aesthetic—occasionally compared to the global phenomenon Squid Game—over logical storytelling or character development. This has led to broader industry discussions regarding the current state of Indian streaming content.

Broader Implications for Indian Streaming

The harsh reception of Student of the Year: After Dark is being framed by critics as a symptom of deeper issues within the Indian digital content landscape. As platforms race to produce high volumes of content to retain subscribers, there is an ongoing debate about whether quantity is being prioritized over quality. When a project carries the weight of a well-known brand like SOTY but fails to deliver technical or narrative competence, it highlights the risks of leveraging established IPs in experimental genres without a solid foundation.

Future Trends and Resilience

Looking forward, the trajectory for Shanaya Kapoor and the SOTY franchise remains uncertain. While the actor has successfully navigated the immediate fallout through humor, the long-term impact on her career and the brand's viability will depend on future project choices. This event serves as a case study in how modern actors must balance the "nepo-baby" discourse and intense public scrutiny while attempting to carve out a professional identity in a high-pressure, algorithm-driven media environment.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the controversy surrounding Student of the Year: After Dark is a clash between high-budget franchise expectations and the realities of critical reception in the streaming age. While the show has faced significant artistic criticism, Shanaya Kapoor’s ability to maintain her public composure suggests a strategic awareness of how to manage an online presence in the face of widespread negative feedback.

Verification Required?

Read the full report from the primary source

Go to The Indian Express