Sports
The Indian Express

‘Where was Siraj?’: Gavaskar and Shastri slam India’s selection as New Zealand fight back

Source Entity

The Indian Express

November 21, 2026
‘Where was Siraj?’: Gavaskar and Shastri slam India’s selection as New Zealand fight back

India's decision to omit Mohammed Siraj from the first Test against New Zealand has sparked debate following a lackluster bowling performance. Coach Sitanshu Kotak defended the tactical selection, even as critics and former players questioned the move alongside the choice to favor Washington Sundar over Ravindra Jadeja.

The Strategic Dilemma: Analyzing India's Omission of Mohammed Siraj

A Captain’s Dream Sidelined

The decision to drop Mohammed Siraj for the first Test against New Zealand in Wellington has sent shockwaves through the cricketing community. Siraj, recently hailed by captain Shubman Gill as a "captain’s dream" following a strong performance at The Oval, found himself excluded from the playing XI in a move that even the skipper admitted was "hard." This sudden shift in personnel suggests a strategic pivot that has left pundits and fans questioning the team management’s rationale.

The Tactical Defense

In the wake of a challenging opening day where the Indian pace attack struggled to maintain pressure on the New Zealand batting lineup, coach Sitanshu Kotak stepped forward to defend the team's selection. While Jasprit Bumrah continued to demonstrate his elite capabilities, the collective inability of the remaining bowlers to contain the opposition highlights the risks inherent in the current selection strategy. Kotak maintains that the decision was rooted in specific tactical planning, though the immediate results on the field have provided significant fodder for critics.

The Gambhir Era of Unconventional Choices

The absence of Siraj is being viewed as part of a broader pattern under head coach Gautam Gambhir, who has developed a reputation for making bold, often polarizing, selection calls. From the decision to promote Washington Sundar to number three in the Kolkata Test against South Africa to the controversial omission of Ravindra Ashwin in Perth, Gambhir’s tenure is marked by a departure from traditional team compositions. This systematic willingness to disrupt the status quo is central to the current debate surrounding the squad’s balance.

The Washington Sundar Conundrum

Adding to the scrutiny is the selection of Washington Sundar over the experienced Ravindra Jadeja. Former Indian opener Wasim Jaffer noted that while Sundar’s inclusion might be justified as a tactical counter to New Zealand’s left-handed batters, the dual impact of dropping both Siraj and Jadeja has left the team looking unbalanced. The decision to prioritize specific matchups over established personnel is a high-stakes gamble that places immense pressure on the remaining players to deliver.

Broader Implications and Future Trends

This series of selection decisions suggests that the Indian team management is prioritizing tactical flexibility and matchup-based strategy over consistency. While this approach aims to exploit specific weaknesses in the opponent, it risks alienating key players and disrupting team synergy. If the current bowling struggles persist, the management will face increasing pressure to revert to a more conventional lineup. The success or failure of this strategy in New Zealand will likely define the long-term selection philosophy of the Gambhir era and determine whether these "unpopular calls" are viewed as visionary or detrimental to the team's stability.

Conclusion

The current controversy underscores the fine line between calculated innovation and tactical overreach. As India moves forward in the Test series, the focus will remain squarely on whether the management can justify these departures from convention with tangible results on the pitch.

Verification Required?

Read the full report from the primary source

Go to The Indian Express